Reliable Felt Roof Repair & Replacement Nearby

Understanding Felt Roofing

Felt roofing, a cost-effective and readily available roofing solution, is commonly used for sheds, garages, and extensions. While not as durable as other roofing materials, understanding its lifespan, common damage causes, and available types is crucial for homeowners and property managers. This information will help you make informed decisions regarding maintenance and potential replacements.

Felt roofing’s relatively short lifespan makes regular inspections and timely repairs essential to extend its useful life and prevent costly damage to the underlying structure.

Felt Roof Lifespan

The lifespan of a typical felt roof significantly depends on the quality of the felt, the climate, and the installation quality. A well-installed, high-quality felt roof might last for 10-15 years, while a lower-quality installation or less durable felt might only last 5-7 years. Factors such as intense sun exposure, heavy rainfall, and extreme temperature fluctuations can all accelerate the deterioration process. For example, a felt roof in a consistently sunny and dry climate may degrade faster due to UV exposure than one in a more temperate climate with less direct sunlight. Regular maintenance, such as cleaning debris and addressing minor damage promptly, can help prolong the roof’s lifespan.

Common Causes of Felt Roof Damage

Several factors contribute to the deterioration and eventual failure of felt roofing. These include:

  • UV Degradation: Prolonged exposure to ultraviolet (UV) radiation from the sun weakens and degrades the felt, making it brittle and susceptible to cracking.
  • Water Damage: Persistent moisture, whether from heavy rainfall, leaks, or poor drainage, can saturate the felt, causing it to rot and lose its structural integrity. This is particularly problematic if the underlying structure isn’t properly ventilated.
  • Physical Damage: Impacts from falling debris, strong winds, or accidental damage can cause tears and punctures in the felt, compromising its waterproof barrier.
  • Poor Installation: Incorrect installation, such as inadequate overlapping of felt sheets or insufficient fastening, can lead to premature failure and leaks.
  • Age and Wear: Over time, even with proper maintenance, felt roofs will naturally degrade due to the cumulative effects of weathering and exposure to the elements.

Types of Felt Roofing Materials

Different types of felt roofing materials exist, each with varying levels of durability and lifespan.

  • Standard Asphalt Felt: This is the most common and least expensive type, typically offering a lifespan of 5-10 years.
  • Mineral-Surfaced Felt: This type includes a layer of mineral granules, which provide added protection against UV radiation and improve its overall durability, extending its lifespan to 10-15 years.
  • Modified Bitumen Felt: This more durable and expensive option offers improved resistance to weathering and temperature fluctuations, extending its lifespan considerably, sometimes exceeding 20 years. It often includes a polymer additive for enhanced flexibility and strength.

Identifying the Need for Repair or Replacement

Regular inspection of your felt roof is crucial for preventing costly repairs and ensuring the longevity of your home’s structure. Early detection of problems allows for timely intervention, minimizing damage and expense. Understanding the signs of both repair and replacement needs is essential for responsible homeownership.

Knowing when your felt roof needs repair or replacement can save you significant time, money, and stress. Ignoring issues can lead to more extensive and expensive problems down the line, potentially compromising the structural integrity of your home. This section will help you identify when professional intervention is required.

Signs Indicating the Need for Felt Roof Repair

A proactive approach to roof maintenance is key to preventing larger, more expensive problems. Regular inspections, ideally twice a year, can help you identify minor issues before they escalate. The following checklist Artikels common signs that your felt roof needs attention.

  • Visible cracks or tears in the felt: These are often easily spotted and represent a breach in the roof’s waterproofing layer, allowing water ingress.
  • Missing or damaged granules: Granules protect the underlying felt from UV degradation. Significant loss indicates weakening and increased vulnerability to the elements.
  • Blistering or bubbling of the felt: This often indicates trapped moisture underneath the felt, leading to potential rot and structural damage.
  • Sagging or uneven areas: These may indicate underlying structural issues or deterioration of the felt itself, potentially leading to leaks.
  • Leaks or water stains inside the building: This is a clear sign of a compromised roof and requires immediate attention.
  • Moss or algae growth: While not always indicative of immediate damage, excessive growth can trap moisture and accelerate felt deterioration.

Situations Requiring Felt Roof Replacement

While repairs address minor issues, some situations necessitate a complete roof replacement. This is a more significant undertaking, but it is often the most cost-effective solution in the long run.

  • Extensive damage: If multiple areas of the roof are severely damaged, or if the damage is widespread, repair becomes impractical and costly. A complete replacement is more efficient and ensures a long-lasting solution.
  • Age and wear: Felt roofs have a limited lifespan, typically 15-20 years. If your roof is nearing or exceeding its expected lifespan, preventative replacement is advisable before significant problems arise. For example, a roof reaching 25 years old, showing significant wear and tear, even without major leaks, is a candidate for replacement.
  • Severe weather damage: Storms, high winds, or heavy snowfall can cause catastrophic damage, rendering the roof irreparable. In such cases, replacement is the only viable option.
  • Underlying structural issues: If the roof’s supporting structure is compromised, simply replacing the felt will not solve the problem. Addressing the structural issues and then replacing the roof is essential.

Consequences of Delaying Necessary Repairs

Ignoring needed repairs can have significant and costly consequences. Small problems left unattended often escalate into larger, more expensive issues.

  • Increased water damage: Leaks can cause extensive damage to ceilings, walls, insulation, and even structural elements, leading to costly repairs and potential mold growth. For instance, a small leak left untreated for months can lead to extensive water damage requiring drywall replacement, insulation removal and remediation, and potentially even structural repairs.
  • Structural damage: Water damage weakens the roof structure and can lead to collapse in severe cases. This can lead to not only roof replacement but also significant damage to the interior of the building.
  • Mold and mildew growth: Moisture trapped within the roof structure creates an ideal environment for mold and mildew, posing serious health risks and requiring specialized remediation.
  • Higher repair costs: Addressing problems early is always more cost-effective than waiting until the damage is extensive.

Finding Local Contractors

Finding reliable contractors for your felt roof repair or replacement is crucial for a successful project. Thorough research and careful selection will save you time, money, and potential headaches down the line. This section will guide you through the process of identifying and evaluating suitable local contractors.

Questions to Ask Potential Contractors

Before engaging a contractor, it’s vital to gather comprehensive information. The following points represent essential information to obtain from each potential contractor.

  • Licensing and Insurance: Inquire about their licensing status and insurance coverage, ensuring they are legally operating and adequately protected against potential liabilities.
  • Experience and Specialization: Determine their years of experience in felt roofing specifically, and ascertain their expertise in handling projects of similar scope and complexity to yours.
  • Detailed Estimates: Request detailed, itemized estimates that clearly Artikel all costs, including materials, labor, and any additional fees.
  • Project Timeline: Seek a clear and realistic project timeline, including start and completion dates, along with contingency plans for potential delays.
  • Warranty Information: Thoroughly review the warranty offered on both materials and workmanship, paying attention to duration and coverage details.
  • References and Reviews: Request contact information for previous clients and check online reviews to gauge their reputation and customer satisfaction levels.
  • Payment Terms: Understand the payment schedule and methods accepted, ensuring a transparent and agreeable payment arrangement.
  • Clean-up Procedures: Confirm their procedures for site cleanup and waste disposal to minimize disruption during and after the project.

Contractor Comparison Table

A comparison table helps to objectively evaluate different contractors based on key criteria. Below is a sample table; remember to replace the example data with your own findings.

Contractor Name Price Estimate Years of Experience Warranty Details
ABC Roofing $5,000 15 5-year workmanship, 20-year material
XYZ Roofing Solutions $4,800 10 3-year workmanship, 15-year material
123 Roofing Co. $5,500 20 10-year workmanship, 25-year material

Organized Contractor Consultation Information

After contacting several contractors, consolidate the gathered information into a structured format for easy comparison. A simple spreadsheet or document outlining each contractor’s name, contact details, price estimate, experience, warranty information, and any other relevant details will prove invaluable in making an informed decision. This organized approach will allow for a side-by-side comparison, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of each contractor’s proposal. Consider using a rating system to further aid your decision-making process.

The Repair Process

Felt roof repairs, when done correctly, can extend the lifespan of your roof and prevent costly replacements. The process involves careful assessment of the damage, selection of appropriate materials, and meticulous application techniques. Successful repairs depend on both the skill of the contractor and the quality of the materials used.

Felt roof repair typically follows a structured process. This involves several key steps, from initial assessment to final sealing, ensuring a durable and weatherproof repair. The specific techniques employed will vary depending on the nature and extent of the damage.

Felt Roof Repair Steps

A typical felt roof repair involves the following steps: Firstly, the damaged area is thoroughly cleaned to remove any loose debris, dirt, or vegetation. This ensures proper adhesion of the repair materials. Next, the damaged section of felt is carefully trimmed, removing any severely deteriorated or loose material. This creates a clean, sound base for the repair. Then, appropriate patching material, usually a compatible felt or a specialized roofing sealant, is selected. The patching material is carefully applied, overlapping the surrounding undamaged felt by several inches. This overlap ensures a watertight seal. Finally, the repaired area is thoroughly sealed with roofing cement or sealant, ensuring a durable and weatherproof finish.

Repair Techniques for Different Types of Damage

Punctures, tears, and water damage require different repair approaches. Punctures are typically repaired using a patch of similar felt material, secured with roofing cement. Tears, depending on their size, may require a larger patch or a more extensive repair involving the replacement of a section of felt. Water damage often requires more extensive work, possibly involving the removal and replacement of several layers of felt to address underlying moisture issues. In cases of significant water damage, a complete roof replacement may be more cost-effective than extensive repairs.

Example of a Felt Roof Repair Job

Let’s consider a scenario involving a small tear in a single-ply felt roof. The repair would begin with cleaning the area around the tear with a stiff brush to remove any loose gravel or debris. Next, the damaged section would be trimmed, creating a clean, rectangular area around the tear. A patch of new felt, slightly larger than the damaged area, would be cut. This patch would be carefully positioned over the tear and secured using a high-quality roofing cement designed for felt roofs. The cement would be applied around the edges of the patch, ensuring a complete seal. Once the cement has dried, the repaired area would be inspected to ensure its integrity and weather resistance. The materials used would include a compatible felt patch, roofing cement, a stiff brush for cleaning, and possibly utility knife for trimming. The entire process, for a small tear, might take an experienced contractor approximately 30-45 minutes. Larger repairs, or repairs involving significant water damage, would naturally take considerably longer.

The Replacement Process

Replacing a felt roof is a more involved process than repair, requiring the complete removal of the existing roofing and the installation of a new system. This ensures a long-lasting, weatherproof roof and prevents future problems. The process typically involves several key stages, from careful material removal to the final installation and cleanup.

A complete felt roof replacement begins with the thorough removal of the old felt roofing. This includes not only the felt itself but also any underlying layers of felt, underlayment, and potentially even existing battens or roof boards depending on the condition. Careful removal minimizes damage to the underlying roof structure. Next, the roof deck is inspected for any damage. Any necessary repairs, such as replacing rotten timbers or fixing damaged boards, are carried out before the new roofing is installed. After the repairs are complete, a new layer of underlayment is often applied to provide additional protection against moisture. Finally, the new felt roofing is installed, typically in overlapping layers to ensure a watertight seal. The final stage involves cleaning up the site, removing all debris and waste materials.

Felt Roof Installation Methods

There are several methods for installing felt roofing, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. The most common methods include the use of torch-on felt, self-adhesive felt, and mechanically fixed felt. Torch-on felt requires a skilled installer to melt the adhesive on the felt using a propane torch, creating a strong bond to the roof deck. This method is highly durable and provides an excellent watertight seal. Self-adhesive felt is easier to install, requiring no special tools or expertise, and is suitable for smaller projects or DIY enthusiasts. However, it may not be as durable or weather-resistant as torch-on felt in extreme conditions. Mechanically fixed felt is secured to the roof deck using nails or staples, offering a cost-effective solution. However, this method may be less watertight than torch-on felt, and proper installation is crucial to avoid leaks. The choice of installation method depends on factors such as budget, the complexity of the roof, and the desired level of durability.

Disposal of Old Roofing Materials

Proper disposal of old roofing materials is crucial for environmental protection and compliance with local regulations. Felt roofing often contains materials that are not biodegradable and can cause environmental harm if improperly disposed of. The old felt should be removed carefully and disposed of at a designated waste disposal facility. Many local councils offer special disposal services for roofing materials, or you can contact a licensed waste removal company. It’s essential to check with your local authority regarding specific regulations and disposal procedures before commencing the roof replacement project. Improper disposal can lead to significant fines and environmental penalties. The removal and disposal of asbestos-containing materials, if present, require special care and should be handled by qualified and licensed professionals.

Cost Considerations

Understanding the cost of felt roof repair or replacement is crucial for budgeting and planning. Several factors influence the final price, and knowing what to expect can help you make informed decisions. This section breaks down the typical costs and explores factors that can impact the overall expense.

The cost of felt roof repair or replacement varies significantly depending on several key factors. A simple repair might cost a few hundred dollars, while a complete roof replacement could reach tens of thousands, depending on the size of the roof and the complexity of the job.

Typical Cost Breakdown

The total cost typically comprises labor costs, materials costs, and potentially permits and disposal fees. Labor costs are influenced by the contractor’s experience and location, while material costs depend on the quality and type of felt roofing materials chosen. Permits, if required, add an additional expense, as does the proper disposal of old roofing materials. For example, a small repair involving patching a minor leak might cost between $200 and $500, while a full replacement on a medium-sized house could range from $5,000 to $15,000 or more, depending on factors discussed below.

Factors Influencing Overall Cost

Several factors significantly impact the final cost of a felt roof project. These include the size of the roof, the complexity of the job (e.g., presence of dormers or chimneys), the condition of the existing roof, the type of felt roofing material selected, the location of the property (labor costs vary geographically), and the contractor’s rates. For instance, a steeply pitched roof presents more challenges and therefore higher labor costs than a flat roof. Using higher-quality, more durable felt roofing materials will increase the initial cost but may lead to longer lifespan and reduced long-term expenses. Similarly, a project requiring extensive repairs or the removal of hazardous materials will incur higher costs.

Financing Options

Many homeowners explore financing options to manage the cost of significant home improvements, such as roof replacement. Several options exist, including home equity loans, which utilize the equity in your home as collateral. Home improvement loans specifically designed for projects like roof replacements are also available from banks and credit unions. Finally, some contractors offer financing plans, allowing you to pay for the project over time with manageable monthly payments. It’s advisable to compare interest rates and terms from different lenders before making a decision to ensure you secure the most favorable financing arrangement for your needs. Careful consideration of interest rates and repayment schedules is essential to avoid long-term financial burdens.

Warranties and Guarantees

Protecting your investment in a new or repaired felt roof is crucial, and a comprehensive warranty or guarantee is a key component of that protection. A well-structured warranty provides peace of mind, ensuring that any defects in materials or workmanship are addressed by the contractor, minimizing potential future costs and disputes. Understanding the terms and conditions of these warranties is therefore essential for every homeowner.

A typical roofing warranty Artikels the specific coverage offered, including the duration of the warranty, the types of defects covered (e.g., material failures, workmanship errors), and any exclusions (e.g., damage caused by extreme weather events beyond a certain threshold). It often details the process for filing a claim, including required documentation and the timeframe for response and repair. The warranty may specify the responsibilities of both the contractor and the homeowner, such as regular roof maintenance. Some warranties are transferable to future homeowners, adding further value to the property.

Warranty Types and Terms

Contractors offer various warranty types, each with different terms and conditions. Some offer a limited warranty covering only specific aspects of the work, such as material defects, for a shorter period (e.g., 1-5 years). Others provide a more comprehensive warranty covering both materials and workmanship for a longer duration (e.g., 10-20 years or even lifetime warranties, though these often have limitations). The level of coverage and the warranty period significantly influence the overall cost of the project. For example, a contractor might offer a 10-year warranty on materials and a 5-year warranty on labor. Another contractor might offer a 20-year warranty on both, but at a higher initial price. A lifetime warranty, while attractive, might only cover material defects and not labor. It’s crucial to carefully review the fine print of each warranty to understand the specific limitations and exclusions.

Comparing Contractor Warranties

When comparing different contractors, it’s vital to not only focus on the price but also meticulously compare the warranties offered. Consider the following aspects:

  • Warranty Duration: How long does the warranty cover materials and workmanship?
  • Coverage Details: What specific defects are covered? Are there any exclusions?
  • Claim Process: What steps are involved in filing a claim? What documentation is required?
  • Transferability: Is the warranty transferable to a future homeowner?
  • Contractor Reputation: Check reviews and testimonials to gauge the contractor’s history of honoring their warranties.

A contractor with a strong reputation and a comprehensive warranty offering demonstrates confidence in their work and provides greater protection for the homeowner. Always request a written copy of the warranty before signing any contract. Don’t hesitate to seek clarification on any unclear terms or conditions. A detailed understanding of the warranty is essential to make an informed decision and ensure long-term protection for your investment.

Choosing the Right Contractor

Selecting the right contractor for your felt roof repair or replacement is crucial for ensuring a long-lasting, high-quality result. A poorly chosen contractor can lead to costly repairs down the line, substandard workmanship, and significant inconvenience. Therefore, thorough research and careful consideration are essential steps in this process.

Choosing a reliable contractor involves assessing their qualifications, experience, and reputation, and ensuring they are properly insured and licensed. This process reduces the risk of encountering problems and ensures the project is completed to the highest standards.

Contractor Credentials and Licensing

Verifying a contractor’s credentials is a vital step in ensuring their legitimacy and competence. This includes checking for valid licensing and insurance. Many jurisdictions require roofing contractors to hold specific licenses, demonstrating they have met certain standards of training and expertise. Confirming the license’s validity directly with the relevant licensing board provides an independent verification of their legitimacy. Insurance, particularly liability and workers’ compensation insurance, protects you from potential financial losses in case of accidents or damage during the project. Requesting proof of insurance provides crucial protection for both the homeowner and the contractor.

Contractor Reputation and Reviews

Investigating a contractor’s reputation involves examining online reviews and testimonials from previous clients. Websites like Yelp, Google My Business, and Angie’s List often contain valuable feedback regarding a contractor’s work quality, professionalism, and responsiveness. Contacting previous clients directly to inquire about their experiences can provide additional insights. Pay close attention to both positive and negative reviews, looking for patterns or recurring themes that might indicate potential issues. A consistently high rating and positive feedback across multiple platforms suggests a reliable and reputable contractor.

Questions to Ask Potential Contractors

Before committing to a contractor, it is essential to ask specific questions to assess their expertise and reliability. This proactive approach helps ensure a smooth and successful project.

  • How long have you been in business, and what is your experience with felt roofing specifically?
  • Can you provide references from previous clients who have had felt roofing work done?
  • What is your process for handling unexpected issues or complications that may arise during the project?
  • What type of warranty or guarantee do you offer on your workmanship and materials?
  • Can you provide a detailed written estimate outlining all costs, materials, and timelines involved?
  • What is your process for obtaining necessary permits and inspections?
  • Are you fully insured and licensed to perform roofing work in this area?
  • What is your payment schedule, and what are your terms of payment?

Maintenance and Prevention: Reliable Felt Roof Repair And Replacement Services Nearby

Regular maintenance is crucial for extending the lifespan of your felt roof and preventing costly repairs. By proactively addressing potential issues, you can significantly reduce the risk of damage and ensure your roof remains in optimal condition for years to come. A well-maintained felt roof will provide reliable protection against the elements and add value to your property.

Proactive maintenance and preventative measures are far more cost-effective than emergency repairs. A small investment of time and effort in regular inspections and simple maintenance tasks can save you substantial expense and inconvenience in the long run. This approach also helps to maintain the structural integrity of your roof, safeguarding your home from water damage and other related problems.

Regular Inspections, Reliable felt roof repair and replacement services nearby

Regular visual inspections are the cornerstone of felt roof maintenance. Ideally, you should inspect your roof at least twice a year – once in spring after the winter thaw and again in autumn before the winter snows. During these inspections, check for signs of wear and tear such as loose or damaged felt, cracked sealant, moss or algae growth, and any signs of water damage like staining or blistering. Pay close attention to areas prone to damage, such as valleys, ridges, and around chimneys or vents. Note any changes from previous inspections and address them promptly. If you are uncomfortable inspecting your roof yourself, consider hiring a professional for a yearly inspection.

Cleaning the Roof

Removing debris and growth is vital to prevent damage. Leaves, twigs, and other debris can accumulate on the roof, trapping moisture and leading to rot and decay. Moss and algae growth can also damage the felt and cause it to degrade prematurely. Regular cleaning, ideally using a soft-bristled brush and a garden hose, will remove this debris and help prevent damage. For stubborn moss or algae, you might consider using a specialized roof cleaning solution, always following the manufacturer’s instructions carefully. Avoid using high-pressure washers, as they can damage the felt.

Repairing Minor Damage

Promptly addressing minor damage can prevent larger, more costly problems. Small tears or punctures in the felt should be repaired immediately using a suitable waterproof sealant. If you notice any loose or lifting felt, use appropriate adhesive to secure it back down. For more significant damage, it is best to consult a professional roofer. Delaying repairs can allow water to penetrate the roof, leading to more extensive and expensive damage to the underlying structure.

Preventing Ponding Water

Ponding water, where water collects on the roof surface, is extremely damaging to felt roofs. Ensure your roof is adequately sloped to allow for proper water drainage. Regular gutter cleaning is essential to prevent blockages that can cause ponding. If you notice any areas where water tends to pool, consult a roofing professional to assess the situation and recommend appropriate solutions, which may include minor adjustments to the roof’s slope or the installation of additional drainage features.

Addressing Signs of Potential Problems

Several signs indicate potential problems requiring professional attention. These include: significant areas of missing or damaged felt, widespread blistering or cracking of the felt, persistent leaks or water stains inside the building, sagging or uneven areas of the roof, and noticeable deterioration of the roof’s flashing around chimneys, vents, or skylights. Ignoring these signs can lead to serious structural damage and costly repairs. It is always best to err on the side of caution and seek professional advice when you notice any concerning signs.

Permits and Regulations

Undertaking felt roof repair or replacement projects often necessitates adherence to local building codes and regulations. Obtaining the necessary permits is crucial not only for legal compliance but also for ensuring the safety and longevity of your roof. Ignoring these regulations can lead to significant penalties, including fines and potential legal action. This section will Artikel the importance of permits and provide guidance on navigating the permit acquisition process.

Local building codes and regulations concerning roofing vary depending on your location. These codes specify requirements for materials, installation methods, and overall structural integrity. They are designed to protect homeowners and the community from substandard workmanship and potential hazards. Common regulations include stipulations regarding the type of felt used, the minimum slope requirements for the roof, and the necessary underlayment for waterproofing. These regulations often change, so checking with your local authority is essential before starting any work.

Obtaining Roofing Permits

The process of obtaining a permit typically involves submitting an application to your local building department or planning authority. This application will usually require detailed information about the project, including the scope of work, the materials to be used, and the contractor’s credentials. You may need to provide architectural drawings or plans, particularly for larger replacement projects. After reviewing the application, the authority will inspect the site to verify the project’s compliance with building codes. Upon approval, they will issue the necessary permit, which must be displayed prominently at the worksite throughout the project’s duration. Failure to obtain a permit before starting work can result in delays, additional fees, and even the need to undo completed work. It’s always advisable to begin the permit application process well in advance of starting any work to allow sufficient time for processing. The exact requirements and timelines can vary, so it is vital to contact your local building department directly for specific information and guidance.

Understanding Local Building Codes

Understanding your local building codes is paramount to ensuring a compliant and safe roofing project. These codes, often available online through your municipality’s website or at the building department, Artikel specific requirements for roof construction, including minimum slope, wind resistance, and fire safety standards. For instance, certain areas may have stricter regulations concerning wind resistance due to prevailing weather patterns. Similarly, areas prone to wildfires might have stricter fire-resistant material requirements. It’s crucial to familiarize yourself with these codes or engage a contractor well-versed in local regulations to ensure your project meets all necessary standards. Failing to comply with these codes can result in structural issues, insurance complications, and legal repercussions.

FAQ Corner

Reliable felt roof repair and replacement services nearbyWhat is the average lifespan of a felt roof?

The lifespan of a felt roof varies depending on factors like climate, quality of materials, and maintenance. Generally, you can expect a felt roof to last between 10 and 15 years.

How much does felt roof repair typically cost?

The cost of felt roof repair depends on the extent of the damage and the contractor’s rates. Minor repairs might cost a few hundred dollars, while more extensive repairs could reach several thousand.

What are the signs I need a roof replacement instead of repair?

Signs you need a replacement include widespread damage, multiple significant repairs needed in a short period, or significant age (beyond 15 years). A professional inspection is recommended.

Can I get financing for a felt roof replacement?

Yes, many contractors offer financing options, or you can explore home improvement loans through banks or credit unions.

Tinggalkan komentar